The Ultimate Alien & UFO Gifts Guide: 10+ Legendary Ideas for Believers

Do you remember the 90s? A time when Alien & UFO gifts, posters, and pop culture treasures captured our imaginations—and when the truth wasn’t just out there; it felt tantalizingly close. For a generation raised on the glow of a CRT screen, the image of Fox Mulder’s “I Want to Believe” poster wasn’t just a prop; it was a mission statement. It represented a deep-seated curiosity, a defiant belief in the face of skepticism, and an endless fascination with the twinkling, silent mystery of the night sky. That feeling—a blend of nostalgia, wonder, and a touch of paranoia—is what defines the true alien and UFO enthusiast.

Finding a gift for that person is about more than just green men and flying saucers. It’s about celebrating a culture of curiosity, skepticism, and wonder. It’s about finding something that speaks their unique language of declassified files, alleged crash sites, and high strangeness. At iheartcryptids.com, we consider ourselves dedicated archivists of this strange and wonderful world. This guide is your declassified dossier, a carefully curated list of top-tier gifts—from impossibly personalized “evidence” to hilariously clever apparel—that truly understand the believer in your life. To fully appreciate the cultural icons and lore behind these gifts, we recommend you start by exploring our comprehensive guide to alien sightings and UFO mysteries.

Just beaming in to shop? → Browse our entire Alien & UFO Collection now!

👽 The “Area 51 Lost & Found” Collection: Your Face in a 90s Alien Encounter

Our signature collection for alien believers is a direct transmission from the golden age of UFO mania. “The Area 51 Lost & Found” teleports you back to the era of grainy camcorders, kitschy roadside attractions, and peak paranormal obsession. The concept is brilliantly simple: we take a photo you provide and our team of digital artists expertly places you into a hilarious, perfectly retro vacation picture with a friendly (or is he?) Grey Alien. It’s the ultimate piece of personalized ‘evidence’ from a desert road trip you always wish you took.

Personalized 1990s Area 51 Alien LED Lamp | Custom Face in Funny Retro Vacation Pic, 90s Kitsch Night Light

This is the undeniable starship of the collection and an absolute masterpiece of personalized decor. It takes the hilarious custom photo—you, beaming with 90s fashion, posing awkwardly next to a classic Grey—and etches it into a high-quality, crystal-clear acrylic plaque. When slotted into its solid wood base and switched on, the image comes to life with a warm, ambient glow. The light catches the etched lines, creating a mesmerizing 3D holographic effect. It’s the perfect night light for a researcher’s study, a stunning accent piece for a living room, or a conversation-starting desk lamp that perfectly captures the kitschy, weird, and wonderful vibe of 90s UFO culture.

Personalized 1990s Area 51 Alien Shirt | Custom Face in Funny Retro Vacation Pic, 90s Kitsch Tee

Wear your classified adventure for all to see. This t-shirt brings the personalized “Lost & Found” design to a high-quality, ultra-soft cotton tee. The printing process ensures every detail of the retro photo—the grainy texture, the slightly washed-out colors, your own smiling face—is captured with perfect clarity. It’s not just a funny shirt; it’s a piece of wearable personal history (that never happened). It’s an instant ice-breaker at conventions, parties, or any casual gathering, immediately identifying you as someone with a top-tier sense of humor and a passion for the paranormal.

Personalized 1990s Area 51 Alien Camping Mug | Custom Face in Funny Retro Vacation Pic, 90s Kitsch Enamel Mug

Perfect for late-night sky-watching sessions, this rugged enamel camping mug brings the 90s desert vibe to any beverage. The custom vacation photo is printed in vibrant, durable colors on the side of this classic, lightweight metal mug. It’s shatterproof and sturdy, making it the ideal companion for camping trips, bonfire discussions about UFO sightings, or just enjoying a cup of coffee at your desk while you sift through the latest declassified documents online. It’s a practical, charming, and deeply personal gift for the adventurer.

Personalized 1990s Area 51 Alien Ornament | Custom Face in Funny Retro Vacation Pic, 90s Kitsch Christmas Gift

Commemorate your close encounter on the Christmas tree. This delightful ornament takes the hilarious “Area 51 Lost & Found” image and preserves it as a holiday keepsake to be cherished year after year. Every holiday season, as they unpack their decorations, they’ll be greeted by the memory of their fictional alien road trip. It’s a wonderfully weird and personal addition to any Christmas tree, a small artifact that tells a big, funny story about their favorite fascination.

→ This 90s-inspired collection is the pinnacle of personalized gifting. Explore all of our incredible custom cryptid portraits and personalized collections here.

🛸 Extraterrestrial Apparel: Top Picks for Shirts & Hoodies

Wear your belief with a healthy dose of humor and undeniable style. This section is a sneak peek of our best standalone alien-themed shirts and hilarious crossovers that unite the entire pantheon of high strangeness. These top picks are guaranteed to be a hit at any comic convention, UFO conference, or casual gathering of fellow believers. In a world where scientific breakthroughs happen every day, these shirts are a fun way to engage with one of humanity’s oldest questions, a question backed by increasingly compelling data. In fact, some feel we have more than enough information to consider the scientific evidence that points to extraterrestrial life by 2025.

Bigfoot Costume Shirt I’m Really An Alien Sasquatch Funny Gifts

This is a work of genius-level crossover humor and a perennial bestseller. The design features the classic, grainy silhouette of Bigfoot from the Patterson-Gimlin film, but with a hilarious twist: a zipper is pulled down on its chest to reveal a classic Grey Alien at the controls, waving sheepishly. The text often reads “Don’t worry, I’m really an alien.” It’s a brilliant and funny take on the theory that Bigfoot might not be a terrestrial primate, but rather a bio-engineered suit or a creature piloted by extraterrestrial visitors. It’s the perfect shirt for the fan who loves to speculate on the wildest connections between legends.

I Want to Believe Funny Alien Christmas Shirt | UFO Pizza Gift Tee

This shirt is a direct and loving homage to the icon that started it all, but with a deliciously cheesy twist. It features the classic “I Want to Believe” saucer, but instead of abducting a cow or a person, its tractor beam is locked onto a giant, floating slice of pepperoni pizza. It’s a perfect blend of 90s nostalgia and modern meme culture, a statement that says, “I want to believe… and I’m also kind of hungry.” It’s a fantastic, lighthearted gift for the holiday season that taps into a universally beloved piece of pop culture.

Bigfoot UFO Mothman Christmas Shirt | Funny Extraterrestrial Cryptid Gift

This is the “all-star team” shirt for the true connoisseur of high strangeness. Why choose one legend when you can celebrate the entire trifecta of American folklore? This design brings together Bigfoot, Mothman, and a UFO (piloted by an alien, of course), often entangled in festive Christmas lights. It’s a chaotic and wonderfully nerdy celebration of the wider world of the unexplained. It’s the ultimate gift for the person whose interests know no bounds, from the deep woods of the Pacific Northwest to the dark skies of West Virginia and beyond.

Dabbing Cryptid Christmas Shirt | Funny Bigfoot, Mothman & Alien Tee

For a gift that is completely of the moment and guaranteed to get a laugh, look no further. This shirt brings the modern “dabbing” meme to the cryptid world with hilarious results. It features Bigfoot, Mothman, and a Grey Alien all striking the pose in perfect unison, decked out in Santa hats for the holiday season. It’s a piece of pure, goofy fun that joyfully embraces internet culture. It’s the perfect gift for the younger believer or anyone who loves a good, silly, contemporary joke.

Funny Bigfoot & Turkey UFO Selfie Shirt | Alien Thanksgiving Gift Tee

Just when you thought the crossovers couldn’t get any wilder, this shirt brings the absurdity to the Thanksgiving table. The hilarious design depicts Bigfoot and a turkey cramming into the frame for a selfie, while in the background, a classic flying saucer hovers ominously. It’s a completely unexpected and wonderfully strange scenario that is perfect for the holiday season. It’s a great, unique shirt to wear for Thanksgiving that is sure to start a memorable conversation with the family.

→ This is just the beginning of the invasion. For a full analysis of over 20+ designs, from funny tees to cozy hoodies, explore our Ultimate Guide to Alien Shirts & Apparel.

✨ Out-of-this-World Decor: Our Favorite Lamps & Ornaments

Transform their space from a simple room into a command center for celestial observation and paranormal research. Here are our favorite standalone decor items that are designed to light up a room and add a touch of extraterrestrial mystery and charm. These pieces are perfect for adding a bit of personality to any believer’s home, office, or secret underground bunker.

Cute Alien Christmas Ornament Extraterrestrial Decor Gift

This ornament is a small package of pure, cosmic charm. Perfect for those who prefer their extraterrestrials cute rather than creepy, this piece features an adorable, cartoonishly rendered Grey Alien. With its big, soulful black eyes and friendly wave, it might be shown wearing a tiny Santa hat, holding a little present, or even piloting a festive, ornament-shaped UFO. Made from lightweight yet durable material, it’s a delightful and heartwarming addition to any Christmas tree. It’s also a perfect stocking stuffer, gift tag, or a small year-round decoration for a desk or bookshelf.

→ Ready to decorate their base? Discover more stunning wall art, unique lighting, and festive keepsakes in our complete guide to the Best Alien & UFO Decor.

Your Search is Over

A gift for a UFO and alien enthusiast is a gift that celebrates imagination, challenges the conventional, and honors an undying sense of wonder. It’s a way of saying that you appreciate their willingness to look up at the night sky and ask the big questions. Whether it’s through a hilarious, personalized piece of “evidence” from a fictional road trip or a clever t-shirt that unites the greatest legends of folklore, the perfect present is one that acknowledges and shares in their passion for the unknown.

At iheartcryptids.com, we celebrate the stories that make us look up at the sky and wonder. We are believers, researchers, and creators, and every item in our store is designed with a genuine passion for the lore and an unwavering commitment to quality and creativity.

Your search for an unidentified fantastic object is over. → Explore all 27+ Alien & UFO gifts in our official collection and find the perfect gift from another world.

Don’t miss the signal. Join our newsletter for exclusive designs and declassified information.